All Posts

Is a workplace dispute ready for mediation, or does it need investigation first? Colin Bourne explains how HR can assess suitability, encourage participation and prepare colleagues.

For many line managers, some of the most difficult workplace situations do not begin with a formal grievance. They begin much earlier, often with a quiet conversation after a meeting, a concern raised during a one-to-one, a complaint about a colleague’s tone, or a growing sense that two members of the team are no longer working well together. At that stage, there may be no written complaint, no formal allegation and no obvious requirement to begin a formal process, yet this i

Understanding the problem - the workplace grievance is often only the visible part of the problem One of the most striking features of workplace disputes is the extent to which the formal grievance can become the visible part of a much wider problem. By the time a grievance reaches HR, the events set out in the complaint may already sit within a longer history of difficult conversations, misjudged exchanges, changing expectations, perceived slights and deteriorating trust. Th

If you have never taken part in mediation, you may be unsure what to expect from the mediator. Will they decide who is right? Should you try to persuade them? And what can you say when you meet them privately? A mediator’s role is to help the people involved have a more useful conversation. They will listen, ask questions and help you explore possible ways forward. They do not act as a judge or make the decision for you. Any agreement remains yours to make. That means you can

Mediation gives people a chance to resolve a dispute on their own terms. Yet simply attending is rarely enough. The way you prepare, listen and respond can make a real difference to what becomes possible, and achieving success in mediation. Start by thinking beyond your opening position. What is most important to you? Which concerns need to be addressed, and where might there be room to move? It can help to consider what the other person may need from the conversation, even i

A dispute can begin with one disagreement and gradually affect much more: a working relationship, a business decision, or the confidence people have in one another. By the time someone suggests mediation, the parties may have spent months repeating their positions without feeling heard. Mediation offers a different kind of conversation. It gives the people involved time and space to explain what matters to them, understand where the difficulties lie, and explore a way forward

Property and estate disputes have a particular ability to become entrenched. On paper, the disagreement may appear straightforward. A boundary is disputed. Beneficiaries disagree about the administration or distribution of an estate. The ownership of property is challenged. A landlord and tenant have conflicting views about responsibility for works. Family members cannot agree what should happen to a property they have inherited. Yet these disputes are rarely about the legal

Most commercial disputes do not begin with a decision to litigate. More often, they start with a problem inside an existing business relationship: an invoice is disputed, a service has not been delivered as expected, a project has overrun, responsibilities are unclear, or one side believes the other has failed to honour what was agreed. At first, both businesses may try to resolve the problem informally. Emails are exchanged, meetings take place and proposals are made. Someti

Workplace disagreements are inevitable. People have different working styles, priorities, personalities and expectations, and most differences can be managed through ordinary conversations and good management. Sometimes, however, a disagreement develops into something more serious. Communication breaks down. Positions become entrenched. A grievance is raised. Someone goes off sick. A manager-employee relationship deteriorates. Colleagues who need to work together begin avoidi